All articles

For families

A new teenage driver: agree the rules before the first drive alone

The first months of driving alone are the riskiest. A written agreement, made together, covers the main risks.

VantageIQ Technologies · October 8, 2026 · 4 minute read

Why the first months matter

Per mile driven, drivers aged 16 to 19 are in fatal crashes at about three times the rate of drivers aged 20 and older, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) says novice teenage drivers rarely crash while an adult is supervising, and have the highest crash rates of all age groups during their first six months of driving unsupervised.

What goes wrong

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) lists eight danger zones for teenage drivers.

  • Inexperience.
  • Teenage or young adult passengers. The CDC says the risk rises with each additional one.
  • Driving at night. Per mile driven, the CDC says the fatal crash rate at night for drivers aged 16 to 19 is about three times that of drivers aged 30 to 59.
  • Not wearing a seat belt. NHTSA says 51% of the teen drivers of passenger vehicles who died in 2024 were unbuckled.
  • Distraction, including phones.
  • Drowsy driving.
  • Reckless driving, which includes speeding. NHTSA says speeding was a factor for 33% of the teen drivers of passenger vehicles, aged 15 to 18, involved in fatal crashes in 2024.
  • Driving impaired.

Your state's rules are the minimum

Every state and the District of Columbia has graduated licensing: a supervised learner's period, then an intermediate license that limits high-risk driving such as at night or with teenage passengers, then a full license. The rules vary from state to state. IIHS says to make sure you know the laws in your state, and not to hesitate to set stricter limits.

What the safety bodies advise often goes further than state law.

  • Practice. NHTSA says many states require parents to certify supervised practice, usually 40 to 50 hours. IIHS suggests a goal at or close to 70 hours, even if your state requires far less.
  • Passengers. The CDC advises no teenage or young adult passengers for at least the first six months after licensing.
  • Night. The CDC advises being off the road by 9 or 10 p.m. for at least the first six months.
  • NHTSA's short list of ground rules: no cell phones, no passengers, no speeding, no alcohol, no driving when tired, and always buckle up.

Put it in writing

The CDC, NHTSA and IIHS all recommend putting the family's driving rules in writing. The CDC and NHTSA say to include the consequences for breaking them. The CDC publishes a Parent-Teen Driving Agreement to download, and the American Academy of Pediatrics publishes the agreement too. It covers these.

  • Promises from the teenager: obey the rules of the road, wear a seat belt and make every passenger buckle up, never text while driving, and never talk on a phone while driving, hands-free included.
  • Limits that the family fills in: how late, how many teenage passengers, and bad weather.
  • A promise from the parent to drive safely and be a role model.

Keep it where everyone sees it. The American Academy of Pediatrics suggests the fridge, or with the car keys. Both it and the CDC say to update the agreement as your teenager gains experience and more driving privileges.

If you use monitoring

An IIHS study published in 2010 fitted the vehicles of 85 teenage drivers with a device that detected speeding, sudden braking or acceleration, and seat belts left undone. Seat belt use improved when violations were reported on websites for the parents, and improved more with alerts in the vehicle. Speeding came down consistently only when the teenagers were alerted, believed a corrected lapse would not be reported, and their parents were receiving reports. The researchers called parent participation the key.

IIHS made a similar point in 2021 about newer in-car features and apps: for alerts to parents to work, parents need to watch them and act when a limit is broken.

Our own view is the same as for location sharing. Tell your teenager what is recorded and who sees it, and write it into the agreement.

Sources

This article is general information for readers in the United States. It is not legal advice, and laws differ from state to state. In an emergency call 911.

More for families